serviam spotlight
Find our legal alerts, news releases, case updates, community tips, and more.
When Routine Administrative Hearings Become Anything But Routine
Most administrative hearings proceed exactly as expected. An officer testifies, photographs and inspection reports come into the record, the appellant explains the circumstances, and the hearing officer issues a written decision. The calendar moves. The file closes. Then there is the other kind of hearing. The one where the appellant arrives with counsel who has never appeared before. The one where an interpreter is requested twenty minutes before the proceeding begins. The one where the only support for a key element is a neighbor’s complaint recorded in an officer’s notes, and the appellant objects. The one where two witnesses give flatly incompatible accounts of the same inspection, and someone has to decide who is telling the truth. These hearings are not rare. They are simply unpredictable. How they are handled in the moment—often without the luxury of research or reflection—frequently determines whether the agency’s decision holds up months later. Why the Administrative Hearing Record Matters So Much Administrative decisions in California are commonly tested by petition for writ of administrative mandamus under Code of...
Serviam Partner Teaches CPOA Police Course on Supervisory Decisions That Make-or-Break Litigation
Kayla Watson, Partner at Serviam by Wright LLP, recently instructed “Supervisory Decisions That Make-or-Break Litigation,” a two-hour virtual presentation offered through the California Peace Officers’ Association (CPOA). The session drew law enforcement supervisors, command staff, and the risk management and legal personnel who support them. The premise was straightforward. By the time a civil complaint is filed, the supervisory record is already fixed. Who assumed command. What was documented. Which report was approved, and what that report failed to articulate. Whether a policy was enforced consistently or selectively. Ms. Watson walked attendees through that record from the perspective of the attorneys who eventually read it—both the plaintiff’s counsel building a claim and the defense counsel working to hold the line. Supervisory Conduct as Litigation Exposure Ms. Watson opened by mapping the litigation framework supervisors operate within, whether or not they are aware of it. Civil claims against California law enforcement agencies rarely stop at the officer who acted. Plaintiffs’ attorneys routinely pursue supervisors...
MOST Recent
LATEST SERVIAM SPOTLIGHT ARTICLES
